European leaders are under pressure to determine on using Russia’s immobilized assets to support Ukraine’s defence, amid unprecedented pressure from the US.
At a pivotal meeting in Brussels, European Union leaders will be asked to make good on a commitment to find desperately required cash for Ukraine, while Kyiv is under the threat to cede ground as Russian forces eke out advances on the battlefield.
“There is no more important demonstration of European defence than backing Ukraine’s fight,” declared the head of the EU executive, adding that “the next days will be decisive in securing this.”
She added that the EU has to assume ownership for its own defence in a world she characterized as “volatile and transactional,” stating: “This is no longer an choice. It is a necessity.”
Funding Options on the Table
Earlier, two key options were suggested to fund Ukraine’s urgent defence and civilian needs for the next years:
- Collective EU borrowing.
- A so-called “compensation loan” backed by Russia’s immobilized funds within the bloc.
Jurisdictional and Financial Hurdles
The Belgian government, which holds the bulk of the €210bn in frozen Russian assets within the EU, has voiced concerns. It argues it lacks sufficient assurances that member states would provide support if the scheme collapsed, possibly leaving Brussels with a multibillion-euro bill.
Compounding these concerns, the Russian Central Bank announced it was pursuing massive damages against the Brussels-based financial institution which holds most of these assets. Belgium also fears that legal systems in nations friendly with Russia could attempt to confiscate European holdings in retaliation.
Crucial National Positions
The Italian government has emerged as an significant voice of caution. The prime minister stated that using Russia’s immobilized assets without a solid juridical foundation would give Moscow a major political win. Similar to Belgium, Italy contends that collective EU debt issuance would be a less risky approach.
“Italy, of course, hold sacred the notion that Russia should be the one to pay for the rebuilding of the nation it invaded, but this result must be accomplished with a solid foundation in law,” she informed parliamentarians.
The German Chancellor stated a commitment to render up to €90bn in Russian assets “usable for Ukraine’s defence.” He put the odds of securing an agreement at “fifty-fifty.”
He informed officials the sum could finance the Ukrainian army for “a minimum of another two years,” and its use would send a powerful message to the Russian leadership.
The Proposed “Compensation Loan” Mechanism
Under the envisioned scheme, the EU would provide Kyiv with a substantial loan funded through issuing bonds. This loan would only be repaid if and when Moscow paid reparations to Ukraine.
European diplomats insist that Russia’s ownership claim on the frozen assets would not be affected. Moscow, on the other hand, argues the move amounts to theft and has promised to respond in kind.
Diplomatic Realities and Consensus
Officials engaged in the summit have indicated the reparations loan is the sole viable option, as using the EU budget would necessitate the agreement of all members.
The Hungarian government, which is hostile to supporting Ukraine, has promised to block any attempt to use the EU budget as collateral for a Kyiv loan. The compensation loan, by contrast, would require only a qualified majority of EU member states.
“A very large majority of member states support the reparations loan,” commented one senior EU official. “Any solution that would require consensus, I don’t think is realistic so we are left with the compensation loan.”
Recently, the EU used special legal measures to indefinitely immobilize the Russian funds, averting the risk of losing its grip on them due to a potential veto from a Russia-aligned government when restrictions come up for extension.
Some has suggested that such authorities could also be used to generate an EU loan for Ukraine secured against the budget, circumventing the need for unanimity. But, other countries argue that would be a legal twist beyond acceptable limits.